I put Ethan’s aside for later and opened Celia’s.
A $15,000 check, dated 2003.
Celia’s wedding. Her voice echoed in my memory: “It’s a small ceremony, Mom. We just want a nice venue.”
The venue had chandeliers and lobster rolls and a string quartet. It was “small” only compared to royal weddings.
A $7,800 transfer in 2007.
“The roof’s leaking, Mom. The baby’s crib got soaked. We don’t have the emergency fund you always talk about. We’re so stressed.”
I’d paid it within an hour. I remember sitting by the phone waiting for a call back that never came. Just a terse text: “Got it. You’re a lifesaver.”
$12,000 in 2011.
Braces for Ethan. I hadn’t hesitated. That boy deserved straight teeth.
$5,000 in 2013.
“A robotics camp,” she’d said. “It could change his life.”
A year later, when her husband got laid off, she called sobbing.
“We’re drowning, Mom,” she’d whispered. “We don’t know what we’d do without you.”
I’d sent another $20,000.
Looking at the figures now, I tried to remember if she’d ever offered to pay any of it back.
She hadn’t.
I opened Peter’s folder.
Thicker.
$25,000 “seed money” for a “sure-thing” startup that fizzled out in six months. George had warned me not to send it.
“He’s making promises that don’t add up,” he’d said, shaking his head.
“I’ll help him get on his feet,” I’d argued.
Peter’s feet never quite found the ground after that. We paid for a used car when his old one “gave up the ghost,” a down payment on a house when he and Meredith “found the perfect neighborhood” they “just couldn’t pass up.” Three semesters of grad school. Hospital bills when his second daughter was born and insurance “messed up the paperwork.” Overdue taxes when he’d “miscalculated.” Always a reason. Always justifiable enough that saying no felt cruel.
Not once did they refuse our help.
But they had refused to come say goodbye to their father.
I slid Peter and Celia’s folders back into the cabinet.
Then I opened Ethan’s.
Only one thing inside: a folded piece of notebook paper, the dime-store lines faint under a clumsy pencil scrawl.
Grandma May,
Thank you for teaching me to make pancakes. I think you are very wise and funny. One day I will take care of you like you take care of me.
Love, Ethan.
He’d written it when he was eleven. He’d handed it to me with both hands, solemn as a little man.
I’d tucked it away and forgotten the exact words.
Until now.
He was nineteen. I didn’t know if he remembered writing that letter. I didn’t know if it still meant anything to him.
But I knew it meant something to me.
People like to say, “Be fair. Treat them equally. Don’t play favorites.”
But maybe fairness isn’t sameness.
Maybe fairness is giving your legacy to the one person who saw you as a person, not as a wallet.
George used to say, “Legacy isn’t what you leave. It’s who you leave it to.”
I’d always thought he meant money.
Looking at Ethan’s letter, I realized he hadn’t.
That afternoon, I packed three cardboard boxes with the kids’ old gifts. Handmade cards, glitter-crusted mugs, picture frames with macaroni peeling off. I didn’t throw them away. I just cleared shelf space. Made room.
Love isn’t in objects.
It’s in actions.
Lately, Peter and Celia’s actions had all said the same thing:
You are useful, not valuable.
That night, I made tea instead of pouring wine. Real tea, the loose-leaf kind George liked. I steeped it properly in the chipped brown pot we’d bought at a yard sale in 1979.
Then I sat at the kitchen table and drank it in the quiet.
Not out of habit.
Out of choice.
For the first time in a long while, I felt something like the beginning of peace.
Ethan’s Call
See more on the next page
Advertisement
<
See more on the next page
Advertisement
