Then she got a text.
Her face went pale.
“What?” I asked.
“Desmond posted bail two hours ago,” she said. “Some hedge fund colleague put up the money. He’s free until trial with conditions—electronic monitoring, no contact with you or Anise.”
I felt exposed. Hunted.
“He can’t hurt you,” Elizabeth said quickly. “You’re safe.”
But I didn’t feel safe.
I felt the way you feel when you realize the snake is loose somewhere in the house and you don’t know which room.
At 9:00 a.m., we entered the courtroom.
It was massive—wood-paneled, high ceilings, every sound echoing. The gallery was full.
And at the defense table sat Desmond.
Tailored navy suit. Hair perfect. Face composed.
He looked like exactly what he was—a successful hedge fund manager.
Not a monster.
Not a murderer.
Just a normal-looking man who tried to poison his mother for money.
Our eyes met across the room.
He smiled.
Not big. Not friendly. Just a small curve of his lips—confident, amused.
And that smile triggered a memory I’d buried so deep I’d convinced myself it wasn’t real.
The night Gerald died.
Desmond was eight.
I heard a crash. Ran into the living room to find Gerald on the floor, clutching his chest, face gray with pain.
“Call 911!” I screamed.
Desmond stood in the doorway.
Watching.
Not moving.
Not crying.
And he smiled.
That same small, curious smile like he was watching an experiment.
I told myself afterward I imagined it.
That children process trauma strangely.
That I misremembered in grief.
But sitting in that courtroom now, seeing that smile again, I knew I hadn’t imagined anything.
Gerald’s heart attack had been sudden.
Natural, I’d thought.
But Desmond had been there. Watching. Smiling.
No.
Impossible.
He was eight.
A child.
He couldn’t have—
Elizabeth squeezed my shoulder as the judge entered. The trial began.
Opening statements were exactly what she warned me about.
The prosecution laid out the evidence methodically: timeline, texts, surveillance, Anise’s testimony.
The defense painted Desmond as a loving son trapped in a stressful marriage, venting in texts “out of context.” A “family dispute.” No actual crime committed.
By lunch I was shaking with rage.
“They’re going to make this sound reasonable,” I whispered to Elizabeth.
She leaned close. “Wait. They haven’t heard the recordings yet.”
That afternoon, Anise took the stand.
She was terrified. Her hands shook as she was sworn in. But when Elizabeth asked her what she’d heard, her voice steadied.
“I was cleaning upstairs on December 1st,” Anise said. “Mr. and Mrs. Callaway were in the master bedroom. Door open. I heard them talking about Christmas dinner. Then Mr. Callaway said—” her voice caught, “—he said it was the perfect opportunity. Heart attack would look natural.”
The courtroom shifted. People leaned forward.
Anise described recording, going to police, wearing a wire.
The defense tried to destroy her—work visa questions, deportation threats, insinuations she had incentives.
Anise’s voice broke, but she didn’t fold.
“I am here because murder is wrong,” she said, crying openly now. “Because I saw her picture and she looked like my mother. And I couldn’t let him hurt her. I knew I might lose everything. But some things are more important than safety.”
The courtroom went quiet in a way that felt reverent.
Then Detective Reeves testified, walking the jury through surveillance and recordings.
They heard Desmond’s voice—cold, casual—saying my death would “look natural.” They heard Sloan practicing crying. They heard Desmond say, I’ve been playing the grieving son my whole life.
Some jurors looked sick.
Desmond sat perfectly still, face blank.
The evidence was damning.
And still—trials are war. Nothing is guaranteed.
On day three, Desmond took the stand.
Elizabeth warned me most defendants don’t testify.
But Desmond believed he could charm a jury the way he’d charmed bankers and boardrooms his whole life.
He talked softly. Respectfully. He cried actual tears.
“My relationship with my mother is complicated,” he said. “I love her. But she’s always been overbearing… suffocating. After my father died, she made me the center of her world. That’s heavy for a child.”
He framed my sacrifice as manipulation. My loneliness as control.
He claimed he set boundaries, and I became obsessive. He claimed the texts were dark jokes.
He made himself look like the victim.
Some jurors nodded.
Doubt crept like poison.
Elizabeth’s cross-examination was fierce.
She read the “jokes” out loud.
Asked about the pharmacy.
He claimed he didn’t remember.
Elizabeth produced receipts for digitalis from a compounding pharmacy in Stamford.
He claimed it was “research for a book.”
She let the jury hear how absurd it was.
And then she asked the question that cracked him.
“Tell the court about your first wife,” Elizabeth said.
Desmond’s face went white.
“That’s not relevant—”
“It goes to pattern, Your Honor,” Elizabeth said.
The judge allowed it carefully.
Elizabeth pressed.
“You were married to Caroline Brennan. She died of an overdose. You inherited five hundred thousand. Did you murder her?”
Desmond denied. Claimed accident. Claimed he was cleared.
Elizabeth’s voice stayed calm.
“Cleared because there wasn’t enough evidence,” she said. “But her family always suspected you. And now your mother is here very much alive because a maid warned her—after hearing you describe a plan that looks a lot like that ‘accident.’ Quite a coincidence.”
Desmond’s mask slipped.
For a flicker, I saw rage.
Then he controlled it again.
No further questions.
The next day, I took the stand.
I’d practiced. I’d rehearsed. I’d become ice.
But sitting in that witness box with Desmond staring at me from fifteen feet away felt like standing at the edge of a cliff.
Elizabeth led me through my testimony gently—my nursing career, raising Desmond alone, the year of silence, the Christmas invitation, Anise’s warning.
“What did you feel when the maid stopped you?” Elizabeth asked.
“Confused,” I said. “Then scared. She was terrified, and I didn’t understand why, but I trusted her. Something in her eyes made me believe her.”
“And when Detective Reeves told you about the poison plot?”
“Like my heart stopped,” I said. “Like the world ended. This was my son. My child. I gave him everything. And he wanted me dead for money I didn’t even know existed.”
“Do you still love him?” Elizabeth asked, and the question hit me harder than anything else.
I looked at Desmond.
His face was neutral, but his eyes were cold. Empty.
“I love the child I raised,” I said slowly. “The boy who cried when he scraped his knee. The boy who hugged me when he was scared. But that boy is gone. The man at that table is a stranger who shares my DNA.”
Desmond’s jaw tightened.
Good.
Let the jury see.
Then the defense attorney Jacob Stern cross-examined me.
He tried to make me the cause.
“How many hours a week did you work?”
“Sixty. Sometimes seventy.”
“Who watched Desmond when you were gone?”
“Babysitters. Neighbors. He was a latchkey kid sometimes.”
“So he spent much of his childhood alone.”
“I had to work,” I said. “We needed food. Rent. His education.”
Stern’s voice turned sharp.
“Best doesn’t always mean good enough, does it?”
Elizabeth objected. Sustained. But the poison stayed in the air.
Stern tried to paint me as bitter, jealous, vengeful.
And then he asked the question designed to break me.
“Isn’t this entire accusation just revenge for being pushed out of your son’s life?”
I felt the courtroom holding its breath.
Ice.
Be ice.
“No,” I said calmly. “He tried to kill me. That’s not revenge. That’s fact.”
Stern stared at me a moment, then sat down.
Eight more days.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
