“Mrs. Whitmore, do you wish to address the court?”
Martin had advised me to stay silent, but something in the judge’s eyes—a glimmer of curiosity, perhaps—made me speak.
“Your Honor, I taught elementary school for forty years. I’ve lived a quiet, honest life. I loaned my necklace to my daughter-in-law because she asked. Because I wanted to help my son’s career. I had no idea about any fraud. The evidence they found in my house isn’t mine. I’ve been set up by people I trusted.”
My voice broke.
“I know how that sounds. I know guilty people always claim they’re innocent, but I’m telling the truth—and if I’m released, I can prove it.”
“How would you prove it?” Judge Howard asked.
Martin shot me a warning look, but I continued.
“My late husband documented the original crimes that led to this foundation. I found his records. They prove Gerald Hartman—Vivien’s father—has been running schemes for over fifteen years. If I can access those documents and show how they connect to the current charges—”
“The documents are in FBI custody,” Reeves said dismissively. “If they’re exculpatory, we’ll review them through proper channels. The defendant doesn’t need to be free to make that happen.”
Judge Howard was quiet for a long moment, studying the papers before her.
Finally, she spoke.
“Bail is set at five hundred thousand dollars. Cash or bond.”
My heart sank.
I didn’t have five hundred, let alone five hundred thousand.
“Your Honor,” Martin tried, “my client is a woman of limited means.”
“Then she’ll remain in custody until trial unless someone posts bail on her behalf.” Judge Howard’s gavel came down. “Next case.”
As they led me out, I saw Michael in the back of the courtroom.
Our eyes met across the space. He looked tired—older than his thirty-five years.
For a moment, I thought I saw doubt in his expression—a flicker of the boy who used to tell me everything, who trusted me completely.
Then Vivien appeared beside him, whispering something in his ear.
His expression hardened.
He looked away.
Back in the holding area, Martin spoke to me through the bars.
“I’m sorry, Mackenzie. I’ll try to get the bail reduced, but it could take weeks.”
“I don’t have weeks.”
“The trial—when will that be?”
“Probably six months. Maybe longer.”
Six months in custody.
Six months—while Vivien and her father covered their tracks, destroyed evidence, prepared their final moves.
“Martin, you have to find a way to get me out. Whatever it takes.”
“I’m working on it,” he said. “But Mackenzie… you need to prepare for the possibility that you’ll be convicted. That you’ll spend the rest of your life in prison for crimes you didn’t commit.”
I gripped the bars.
“I won’t accept that. I can’t.”
After he left, a guard brought me a message—not from my lawyer or Dorothy, but from an inmate being released, a woman I’d never met.
She handed me a folded piece of paper.
“Someone paid me to give you this,” she said, and walked away.
I unfolded the note.
The handwriting was unfamiliar, the message chilling.
Mackenzie, you’ve been a problem for too long. Dale should have stayed quiet. You should have stayed ignorant. Now you’re going to stay silent permanently. An accident in custody is easy to arrange. Unless you want to survive, you’ll sign a confession admitting everything and clearing Vivien and Michael of all wrongdoing. You have 48 hours to decide. After that, you become another tragic statistic.
GH
Gerald Hartman had reached me even in federal custody.
He could get to me anywhere.
And he was giving me a choice.
False confession—or death.
My hands shook as I hid the note under my mattress.
The walls of my cell seemed to close in.
I’d thought federal custody meant safety.
I’d been wrong.
Somewhere in this building—or in the cells around me—someone was watching, waiting, ready to carry out Hartman’s threat if I didn’t comply.
I had forty-eight hours to figure out how to survive.
I didn’t sleep that night.
Instead, I lay in my cell thinking about every detail of the past five years—every interaction with Vivien, every conversation with Michael—and I realized something crucial.
I had more information than Gerald Hartman thought I had.
When you’re a teacher for forty years, you learn to notice things. Small inconsistencies in behavior. Lies hidden beneath polite conversation.
I’d noticed things about Vivien from the beginning.
I just hadn’t trusted my instincts.
But I’d kept records.
Not because I suspected fraud, but because that’s what teachers do.
We document everything.
At six in the morning, I asked the guard to contact Martin.
“It’s urgent,” I said. “A matter of life and death.”
He arrived two hours later, looking concerned.
“Mackenzie, what’s happened?”
I slid Gerald Hartman’s threat note across the table.
“I received this yesterday. I have forty-eight hours to sign a false confession or he’ll have me killed in custody.”
Martin’s face went pale as he read.
“This is a direct threat. We need to show this to the FBI immediately.”
“No. Not yet.” I leaned forward. “Martin, I need you to listen very carefully. I’ve been thinking about everything that’s happened, and I realize I have evidence—evidence I’ve been keeping without even knowing it was important.”
“What kind of evidence?”
“Five years ago, when Michael first introduced me to Vivien, something felt off. I couldn’t explain it—just a teacher’s intuition that she wasn’t quite what she seemed. So I started keeping a journal. Nothing dramatic—just notes about our conversations. Things she said or asked about. Dates. Times. Subjects discussed.”
Martin’s eyes widened.
“You documented every interaction?”
“Not every one, but most. Including the day she asked about my jewelry, the times she and Michael visited and seemed particularly interested in the basement, the questions about Dale’s career in the school district.” I paused. “The journal is in my house, hidden in a place Vivien would never think to look—inside the binding of my photo album from Dale’s memorial service. I slit the backing open and slipped the pages inside.”
“The FBI searched your house,” Martin said carefully. “They would have found it.”
“Not unless they dismantled the album. And why would they? It’s just a memorial book. They were looking for financial documents, not a grandmother’s diary.”
I grabbed his hand, my grip tight.
“Martin, that journal proves I’ve been suspicious of Vivien from the start. It shows a pattern of her asking specific questions about Dale’s papers. It contradicts Michael’s testimony that I was willingly involved.”
Martin was already making notes.
“If we can retrieve this journal—there’s more. Three years ago, Vivien asked to borrow my computer to check her email. She was on it for about twenty minutes. At the time, I thought nothing of it. But afterward, I noticed my email password had been changed. I assumed I’d forgotten it and reset it myself.”
My mouth felt dry.
“Now I realize she was installing something to monitor my communications.”
“Spyware?”
“Yes. But here’s what she didn’t know.” I leaned in. “I got a new computer last year. My old one is in the basement still functioning. If the spyware is still on it, can that be traced back to Vivien?”
“Possibly,” Martin said, writing faster. “If we can show when it was installed and link it to her access.”
“What else?” he asked.
“Last Christmas, Vivien gave me a digital photo frame as a gift. Said she’d loaded it with family pictures. I kept it in my living room.” My stomach tightened. “I think it had a camera in it—one of those surveillance devices the FBI found. If we can prove she gave it to me, it shows premeditation.”
Martin looked up.
“Do you have the card she gave you with the gift? Any documentation?”
“Better.” I forced out something like a grim smile. “I thanked her in a Christmas card—specifically mentioning the photo frame and how thoughtful it was. I kept a copy of what I wrote. I always do, in case I need to remember what I gave or said to people.”
Old teacher habits.
Document everything. Keep copies. Never assume people remember things the way you do.
Martin stared at me.
“Mackenzie… you’ve been building a case without even knowing it.”
“I’ve been protecting myself,” I said quietly. “After Dale died, I felt vulnerable—alone. I started keeping better records of everything just to feel more secure. I never imagined I’d need them like this.”
Martin tapped his pen against the pad.
“We need to get that journal, the old computer, and your card copies. But the FBI has your house sealed as a crime scene. We can’t just walk in.”
“Then we make them look,” I said. “We tell them there’s exculpatory evidence they missed. Once they find the journal, they’ll have to consider it.”
Martin hesitated.
“Gerald Hartman’s threat. If we show the FBI, they’ll increase your protection. But it also means going public with information that might provoke him to act faster.”
“I know,” I said, voice steady now. “But I can’t sign a false confession. Too many people have already been hurt by these lies.”
I thought of Evelyn Patterson and the other elderly victims.
“Besides,” I added, “I have one more card to play. Something that connects everything together.”
Martin’s eyes sharpened.
“What is it?”
“Dale wasn’t just documenting Gerald Hartman’s embezzlement,” I said. “He was documenting Vivien too. She was involved in her father’s schemes even back then—fifteen years ago—when she was barely twenty. Dale recognized her when Michael brought her to meet us. Recognized her from surveillance photos connected to the Miami fraud case. That’s why he told Michael to be careful—to take things slow with her.”
Michael thought his father was being overprotective.
He didn’t know Dale was trying to warn him.
“Did Dale tell you this?” Martin asked.
“He tried to—near the end. He was sick, not thinking clearly sometimes, and he kept talking about the Hartman girl and how she was dangerous. I thought he was confused, mixing up people from his past.”
Tears burned my eyes.
“I didn’t realize he was talking about Vivien. He died trying to protect Michael from her—and I didn’t understand until now.”
Martin was quiet for a moment.
“If Dale recognized Vivien—if he documented that—his letter mentions it.”
“Not directly,” I said, “but he says he knew Michael was in danger from people connected to the original crime. He was talking about Vivien. And if we search his documents more carefully, I think we’ll find evidence that he tried to investigate her background before he died.”
Martin exhaled slowly.
“This changes everything. It means Vivien didn’t just target Michael randomly. She knew Dale had recognized her. Marrying Michael was about neutralizing the threat Dale posed.”
The pieces clicked together with horrible clarity.
Dale’s death.
The doctor said it was a heart attack. But he was only sixty-three—relatively healthy.
What if—
“Mackenzie,” Martin warned, reading my face, “don’t go there. Without evidence, it’s just speculation.”
But I couldn’t stop the thought.
What if Gerald Hartman had arranged Dale’s death?
What if my husband had been murdered to silence him—and I’d spent seven years never questioning it?
Martin’s voice stayed firm.
“Focus on what we can prove. Let me talk to the FBI about the journal and the other evidence. In the meantime, you need to be careful. Don’t accept food or drink from anyone except guards you trust. Don’t go anywhere alone. If Hartman has someone inside, they’ll be looking for an opportunity.”
After Martin left, I requested a meeting with Agent Dos Santo.
The guards seemed surprised, but they arranged it for that afternoon.
Dos Santo arrived looking skeptical.
“Mrs. Whitmore, your lawyer said you have information to share.”
“I do. But first I need to know—have you found Dale’s documents in my kitchen? The ones hidden in the cookbook?”
“We found them. They’re being analyzed.”
“Have you traced the origins of the Riverside Foundation’s funding? Have you connected it back to the school district embezzlement?”
Dos Santo’s expression shifted slightly.
“We’re pursuing several lines of investigation.”
“Then you know Gerald Hartman is behind all of this,” I said, voice steady. “That he’s been running criminal operations for over fifteen years. That my husband documented his original crimes and died before he could report them.”
“We’re aware of Gerald Hartman’s history.”
“Are you aware he’s threatened to have me killed in custody if I don’t sign a false confession?” I pulled out his note. “This was delivered to me yesterday by another inmate. Someone paid her to give it to me. Which means Hartman has access to this facility—can reach me even here.”
Dos Santo read the note, her jaw tightening.
“Why didn’t you report this immediately?”
“Because I needed to think,” I said. “To understand what I’m really dealing with.”
I leaned forward.
“Agent Dos Santo, I know how this looks. I know the evidence suggests I’m guilty. But I’ve been keeping records for five years—a journal documenting every suspicious interaction with Vivien. Every odd question. Every moment that felt wrong. That journal is in my house, hidden inside my photo album from Dale’s memorial service. If you find it, you’ll see I’ve been suspicious of her from the beginning. You’ll see this isn’t about me being complicit. It’s about me being too polite to act on my instincts.”
Dos Santo studied me.
“If this journal exists, why didn’t you mention it before?”
“Because I didn’t realize it mattered,” I said. “I thought I was just being an anxious mother-in-law, writing down concerns that made me seem paranoid. I never imagined it would become evidence in a criminal case.”
I met her eyes.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
