I hadn’t heard from him in decades. His statement was dated six months earlier.
My sister Judith visited me in Portugal in May 2005, already experiencing early symptoms of her illness. She brought legal documents for my review, including a will dated April 2005. She was completely lucid during this visit. The will explicitly stated that her son, Bradley Anderson Tilman, would inherit the entire Anderson estate upon reaching age twenty-one, with her husband, Roland Voss, serving as executor only until that time. She told me, “I need someone to know the truth in case Roland tries something.”
“She knew him better than I realized,” Teddy had added in his statement.
My ancient Android phone was in my pocket, barely holding a charge on a good day. I pulled it out with shaking hands and started taking pictures. I didn’t care about angles or clarity. I just needed proof.
Bank records showing Roland moving money the day after my mother’s funeral. A confession from a man named Mitchell Brener, a professional document forger. His notes listed every job he’d done, including one for Roland in December 2005. An email chain between my uncle Teddy and the firm that owned this briefcase, Peton, Morse and Associates.
We’ve been searching for Bradley for two years, one email said. Roland claims he left the state, possibly passed away. We need Bradley’s testimony to complete the federal case.
By the time I was done, my phone held fifty-three photos—blurry, crooked, smudged by my greasy fingers, but clear enough.
I stacked the documents carefully, put them back in the briefcase, and wiped the trunk carpet with the cleanest part of my shirt to hide the worst of the fingerprints. By the time Nolan walked back across the street with his coffee, I was crouched by the rear wheel, finishing his rotation like it was just another Tuesday.
“All set?” he asked, still half-focused on his phone.
“Yes, sir. You’re good to go. That’ll be forty-nine ninety-nine.”
He handed me a hundred, told me to keep the change, and drove away—without ever knowing he’d just delivered my salvation.
I watched his Mercedes disappear into traffic, then wiped my hands on a rag and walked straight to Dale’s office.
“I need to make a call,” I said. “Personal emergency.”
Dale took one look at my face and didn’t ask questions.
“Take all the time you need, Brad.”
I used the shop’s ancient computer to look up the letterhead I’d seen: Peton, Morse and Associates — Forensic Accounting and Financial Investigation. Their office was downtown, in a glass building I’d driven past a thousand times.
My fingers trembled as I dialed the number. The receptionist answered with a polished, professional tone.
“Peton, Morse and Associates, how may I direct your call?”
“My name is…” My throat went dry. “My name is Bradley Tilman. Bradley Anderson Tilman. I think you’re investigating my family.”
There was a small pause. Then her voice sharpened.
“Mr. Tilman, please hold. And please don’t hang up.”
Thirty seconds later, another voice came on the line—female, steady, and urgent.
“Mr. Tilman, this is Janet Peton. We’ve been trying to find you for two years. Your uncle hired us to investigate your mother’s estate. Can you come to our office as soon as possible? We have evidence that will change everything, but we need you.”
The law offices of Peton, Morse and Associates occupied the top floor of a downtown Columbus high-rise, all glass and steel and carefully neutral carpets. I’d driven past it for years on my way to jobs that paid barely enough to survive. I’d never imagined I’d have a reason to go inside.
Janet met me herself in the lobby—a woman in her sixties with silver hair pulled into a low bun and sharp eyes that looked like they’d seen every kind of lie. She shook my hand firmly.
“Mr. Tilman, I’m very glad you called,” she said. “Your uncle never believed the will was legitimate. He always insisted your mother did not intend to leave you with nothing.”
She led me into a conference room with floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the Columbus skyline. On the wall was a large screen already connected to a video call. My uncle Teddy’s face appeared a second later.
His hair was white now, his skin more lined, but his eyes were the same warm brown as my mother’s.
“Bradley,” he said, leaning closer to the camera. “My goodness. You look just like your mother.”
My throat tightened. “Hi, Uncle Teddy.”
The story came out in pieces, each one landing like another weight on my chest.
Teddy had hired Peton, Morse and Associates in 2022 after hearing about a federal case involving a professional forger named Mitchell Brener. When the FBI raided Brener’s storage unit, they found what he called his “insurance policy”—detailed records of every forgery he’d ever created.
One of those entries was for my stepfather, dated December 2005.
Janet slid a photocopy of the log across the table.
“Look here,” she said softly.
December 12, 2005 — Client: Roland Voss. Payment: $50,000 cash. Task: Forge will for Judith Anderson Voss. Subject terminally ill. Original will leaves estate to son. Client wants full inheritance. Easy trace job using sample signatures. Subject unable to write. Unlikely anyone questions it.
I stared at the page until the words blurred.
Roland had used my mother’s own money—fifty thousand dollars—to steal everything else she’d meant for me.
Teddy cleared his throat on the screen.
“Your mother came to see me in Portugal seven months before she passed,” he said. “She was starting to have symptoms, but she was completely lucid. She showed me her real will. You were to inherit everything when you turned twenty-one—the Anderson shipping fortune, the estate, all of it. Roland was to receive a modest stipend for life, enough to live comfortably but not enough to fund the lifestyle he wanted. She was trying to protect you and, honestly, trying to protect him from himself.”
Janet pulled another folder from the stack.
“We have a certified copy of that original will,” she said. “Your mother filed it with a law firm in Lisbon. We believe she did that because she didn’t trust anyone affiliated with Roland in Ohio. She anticipated he might try something reckless.”
The FBI had been building their case for months—wire fraud, mail fraud, estate fraud, conspiracy. Brener’s notes, Teddy’s documentation, and the forensic analysis in Nolan’s briefcase gave them a powerful foundation. But what they didn’t have was me.
“We need your testimony,” Janet said. “We need you to talk about your mother’s mental state in her final months, about the will reading, about the parking lot conversation, the five hundred dollars, everything.”
Three days later, I sat in a federal building conference room in downtown Columbus, across from an FBI agent and a court reporter. I gave a deposition that lasted six hours.
I told them about my mother forgetting my name, about her calling nurses by dead relatives’ names during the month that “sound mind” will was supposedly signed. I told them about Roland’s phone calls to his lawyer while she lay in a hospital bed. I described the parking lot, the winter air, the envelope of cash, and the words that had carved a scar into my life.
“You’re not blood, Bradley.”
At one point, the agent stopped writing and just looked at me.
“You lived like this for nearly three decades because of that forgery,” he said quietly.
“Yeah,” I answered. “I did.”
The arrest happened on a Tuesday, exactly three weeks after I’d opened Nolan’s trunk.
I watched from across the street as FBI agents walked into Roland’s country club outside Columbus, interrupting his weekly golf game. The place was all manicured greens and American flags fluttering near the clubhouse—one of those places that looked like the picture of success.
He came out in handcuffs, his polo shirt untucked, his silver hair mussed for the first time I’d ever seen. The members stared, some pretending not to look, others openly gawking.
Then Roland saw me.
His expression flickered—from confusion to recognition, from anger to something I’d never seen on his face before.
Fear.
“You!” he shouted, trying to pull away from the agents. “You did this! You ungrateful nobody!”
I stepped closer to the edge of the crime-scene tape.
“No, Roland,” I said, my voice steady. “You did this to yourself the day you decided I didn’t count as family.”
His jaw clenched. I kept talking.
“Turns out blood does matter—just not the way you thought.”
A Bentley screeched to a stop nearby. His biological daughter, Penelope, climbed out, her heels sinking into the grass as she hurried toward the commotion.
“Dad!” she cried, rushing forward until an agent held up a hand to stop her.
When she saw me, her face hardened.
“You destroyed my father,” she said. “He raised you. He gave you everything.”
I shook my head slowly.
“He gave me nothing,” I said. “He took everything my mother meant for me and handed me five hundred dollars and a lifetime of wondering why I wasn’t enough. Your father is going to prison because he broke the law. The money you’ve been living on—the cars, the vacations, the boutique that never turns a profit—that was all stolen from my mother’s estate. From me.”
She stared at me like I was speaking another language. The agents guided Roland into a waiting federal vehicle. The doors shut with a heavy thud, and for the first time in twenty-eight years, I felt something loosen inside my chest.
The trial moved quickly by federal standards.
Roland’s attorneys tried to discredit Brener, arguing he was lying to reduce his own sentence. They tried to suggest Teddy was bitter about being cut out of the original family fortune. They tried to paint me as a disgruntled stepson chasing money I hadn’t earned.
But facts are stubborn things.
The forged will. The bank records showing money transfers in the days after my mother’s funeral. Teddy’s testimony. My deposition. The forensic handwriting analysis. And then the final devastating piece—a recording Brener had secretly made of Roland back in 2005.
Paranoid about being cheated, Brener had recorded many of his high-paying clients without their knowledge. In the audio the jury heard, Roland’s voice was clear.
He talked about my mother’s illness.
He discussed her original will leaving everything to me.
He explained exactly how he wanted the forged document to read and how it needed to look “shaky enough to be believable for someone sick, but not so shaky a judge questions it.”
The verdict came on a Thursday.
Guilty on all counts.
The judge, a serious woman with kind eyes, read out the sentence: fifteen years in federal prison, with no possibility of parole for ten. Restitution of ninety-four million dollars—the value of the stolen estate—plus interest and penalties, bringing the total to one hundred twenty-seven million.
Federal marshals seized Roland’s assets within days. The mansion in Upper Arlington he’d bought after selling the Anderson estate. His investment accounts. The commercial properties he’d purchased with my mother’s money. Everything was liquidated to satisfy the judgment.
Penelope tried to argue that her boutique in German Village was separate—that it had been funded by gifts, not stolen money. But gifts bought with misused funds don’t stay gifts for long. In the end, she kept only what she’d actually earned from her own work, which wasn’t much.
My first phone call after the verdict was to Dale at the tire shop.
“I’m not going to leave you hanging,” I told him. “I’ll work two more weeks. I’ll help you find somebody good and train him up.”
For a second, Dale didn’t say anything. Then he let out a laugh—the first real belly laugh I’d ever heard from him.
“Brad, you don’t owe me a thing,” he said. “You just had more money dropped on you than I’ve ever seen in my life. Go live it.”
“You gave me a job when nobody else would,” I said. “Two weeks. That’s what decent people do.”
My Uncle Teddy flew in from Portugal for the final asset transfers. It was the first time I’d seen him in person since I was thirteen.
He stepped out of the arrivals gate at John Glenn Columbus International Airport in a light linen suit that probably cost more than I used to make in three months, but his hug felt like home.
“Your mother loved you more than life itself,” he said later, standing with me in the foyer of the house that had once belonged to Roland and now—legally—belonged to me. “She would be so proud that you survived all of this without letting it turn you cruel.”
The money came in waves.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
