“Sister’s wedding was great,” she said brightly, glancing at Lily as if to confirm. “So, Cat, when’s yours?”
The table chuckled. Even the turkey knife in my father’s hand paused like it didn’t know which side to take. Lily kept her eyes on her plate. Too still, too careful. That told me everything.
For years, I would have laughed it off, let the jab slip under my skin, pretended it didn’t hurt. But not this time. Not after everything they’d buried.
I set my fork down gently.
“I already had mine,” I said, my voice steady. “Six months ago.”
The shift in the room was immediate, like all the air had been yanked out at once. I waited a beat, let the silence land, then added, “You got invitations.”
Forks froze. Eyes widened. My mother’s smile collapsed. My father blinked like he wasn’t sure he’d heard correctly. Across from me, Lily’s face didn’t move. That was the tell—she knew exactly where this was going, and she couldn’t stop it.
“Cat,” my father said carefully, “we never got any invitations.”
There it was. The lie, the familiar deflection, the story they’d rehearsed without even knowing they were rehearsing it. I felt something inside me settle. Not anger. Not revenge. Clarity.
“I figured you’d say that,” I replied softly.
I reached into my bag, not rushing, not dramatic, and placed my phone on the table. The screen glowed, reflecting in the stemware, the candlelight catching its edges like a blade. Every pair of eyes locked onto it. This was the line I’d never crossed before. The boundary I’d never drawn. The moment I stopped allowing myself to be rewritten.
And as I tapped the screen to open the receipts, the truth rose in my chest like a tide ready to break.
The moment my thumb touched the screen, the room shifted. It wasn’t loud. It wasn’t chaotic. It was quiet in the way storms get quiet right before they level a coastline.
The receipts opened in a neat little list—four deliveries, four signatures, all marked received. I zoomed into the first one and rotated the phone so the entire table could see. The looping, confident signature at the bottom was unmistakable.
Lily.
My mother gasped softly, her hand flying to her mouth. My father leaned forward like he needed to see the truth up close or it wouldn’t count. Ryan stiffened in his chair, his eyes darting from the screen to his wife like someone had suddenly spoken a language he didn’t know she understood. Lily didn’t move. Her face didn’t even twitch.
I could feel my pulse in my fingertips, but my voice came out calm. Too calm.
“These were delivered April 23rd,” I said. “All four invitations signed for by Lily.”
Dead silence again. But this time, it wasn’t surprise. It was exposure.
“Cat,” my father whispered, “this… this must be a mistake.”
“It’s not,” I said, swiping to the next screenshot. “This is the tracking log from the postal service. Priority mail. Signature required. All confirmed. All delivered.” I paused, then added quietly, “And all intercepted.”
My mother shook her head. “No. No. No. That makes no sense. Lily would never—”
“Oh, stop,” I said gently. Not harsh. Just done. “You keep saying what Lily wouldn’t do, but you never look at what she actually does.”
That landed. My mother froze. Ryan finally spoke, his voice low.
“Lily, did you sign for these?”
Lily blinked. Not slow, not thoughtful, but mechanical, like she was trying to reboot her expression.
“I don’t remember. Maybe I… Sometimes I grabbed the mail, but I didn’t see any invitations.”
I stayed quiet. I’d learned a long time ago that silence is sometimes louder than any accusation, so I let it sit.
My father, staring hard at Lily now, said, “You didn’t see four packages from your sister. Around the time you knew she was engaged?”
“It’s not my job to track everyone’s mail,” Lily snapped back, the first crack in her composure, sharp enough to cut.
It was the wrong move.
My mother reached toward her. “Sweetheart—”
“No,” I said, my voice still calm. “Let her talk. She’s been talking for years.”
Lily glared at me. “What’s that supposed to mean?”
I didn’t answer the question. I swiped to the last screenshot—the email log Ethan helped me access.
“This,” I said quietly, “is the activity log for the family email account. The wedding announcement email I sent in April was opened from this house, then deleted immediately.”
My father’s jaw tightened. “Who has access to that account?”
Everyone at the table knew the answer. Everyone always knew the answer.
Lily finally broke.
“I didn’t delete anything,” she said, too fast.
I tilted my head. “Then why does it show your device ID?”
Her mouth opened, closed, opened again. “I… maybe I clicked it by accident. I don’t know. Why are you attacking me?”
“I’m not attacking you,” I said. “I’m showing you what you did.”
My mother exhaled harshly. “Why would Lily ever hide your invitations? Why would she sabotage your wedding? That’s ridiculous.”
There it was. The sentence she’d been polishing my entire life. The defense she used for every bruise Lily ever left on me.
“Why?” I repeated. “Because my wedding happened in June. Hers was in September.” I turned to Lily. “Because you didn’t want anyone talking about mine before yours.”
Lily flinched like I’d slapped her with the truth she’d been trying to outrun.
“That’s insane,” Lily hissed. “You always twist things to make me look bad.”
“No,” I said, voice steady. “You did that yourself.”
Ryan’s chair scraped the floor as he stood. “Lily, is this true?”
She stared down at her napkin, her breath shaking.
“I don’t… This is… Everyone always thinks Cat is so innocent. She never needs anything. She never wants anything. She ruins nothing for anyone. She just exists and makes everyone feel—”
“Feel what?” I asked softly.
She shot to her feet. “Feel guilty. Feel small. Feel like she doesn’t even have to try.”
Ah. There it was. The real confession—not about the invitations, but about every year before them.
I leaned back slightly. “So you hid my wedding because what? Because it was quiet? Because it didn’t compete with your six-tier cake and rented string quartet?”
“That’s not—” she gasped.
But the truth was already hanging in the air like smoke.
“Cat,” my father said desperately. “We didn’t know. If we’d known, we would have—”
“You would have come,” I finished for him. “After years of missing every milestone. After forgetting every birthday. After making sure Lily’s needs always came first.”
He closed his eyes. My mother’s face twisted.
“You can’t put all that on us. We did our best.”
“No,” I said. “You did your best for Lily. For me, you did the bare minimum and called it fairness.”
Lily sat down abruptly, her shoulders collapsing. Even she couldn’t defend that. The weight of decades pressed into my chest, not as grief anymore, but as clarity.
I looked at each of them—the people I had begged silently for years to see me. And I finally told the truth.
“I didn’t lose my family tonight,” I said. “I just stopped pretending I had one.”
My mother gasped. “Cat, don’t you dare talk like that.”
“Why?” I said. “Because it threatens the story you built? The one where Lily is perfect, Dad is neutral, you are the peacemaker, and I’m the problem?”
“No one said you’re the problem,” Dad whispered.
“You didn’t need to say it,” I replied. “You showed it over and over.”
Ryan sank back into his chair as if watching the pieces of his marriage rearrange themselves into a shape he didn’t recognize. Lily whispered, “Cat, please.”
That single word—“Please”—carried years of fear, guilt, and the sudden realization that her control was gone.
I stood slowly, pushing my chair back with a soft scrape. “I’m done begging for a place at this table,” I said. “I’m done asking you to show up for me. I’m done pretending Lily’s choices don’t hurt me. I’m done accepting your silence as anything but agreement.”
I took a breath. “I’m done.”
My father stood too, reaching out. “Cat, don’t go. We can talk.”
“We are talking,” I said. “The first time, and for the last time under these terms.”
My mother’s eyes brimmed. “We can fix this.”
See more on the next page
Advertisement
